JAKARTA – The dream of a future of environmentally friendly hydrogen-powered cars has turned into a nightmare for hundreds of car owners in California. Drivers who purchased the Toyota Mirai, Toyota's flagship fuel cell vehicle, have now filed a lawsuit against the manufacturer and other parties. They allege they were misled about the feasibility of a hydrogen refueling network.
As reported by Teslarati on Monday, July 14, with collapsing infrastructure and soaring hydrogen prices, many Mirai drivers are now stuck with car payments they can't even use. This lawsuit comes amid growing criticism of Toyota and early proponents of hydrogen-powered mobility. Many question whether the technology is being pushed too quickly into an unprepared market.
One plaintiff, Sam D'Anna, experienced this bitter reality shortly after purchasing a $75,000 Toyota Mirai in July 2022. His hydrogen tank was nearly empty, and the nearest refueling station was out of service. D'Anna is now a plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit alleging fraud, negligence, and violations of consumer protection laws. His Mirai now sits abandoned, but he still has to pay a monthly mortgage of nearly $1,100.
Yet, California's hydrogen vision at its peak seemed ambitious and achievable. The state pledged tens of millions of dollars to build a network of charging stations, and automakers like Toyota, Hyundai, and Honda introduced zero-emission hydrogen-powered vehicles. The concept was appealing: refueling in minutes and emitting only water vapor, a promising alternative to electric vehicles, which were still in their infancy.
However, implementation on the ground lags far behind publicity. California currently has only about 50 hydrogen filling stations. By 2024, Shell had even withdrawn from the market and closed several locations. Worse still, when hydrogen stations do become available, they often face maintenance issues and inconsistent supply. Hydrogen prices have skyrocketed, from around $70 to nearly $200 for a full fill-up.
Meanwhile, Alex Black, Chief Marketing Officer at EpicVIN, explained that these problems go beyond infrastructure.
"Many lack confidence in this technology, largely because they haven't seen much of it out there, there aren't many places to fill it, and they've heard about previous problems or recalls," he said.
Negative public sentiment can create a vicious cycle: reduced demand, decreased investment, and stalled station construction.
Toyota's investment in hydrogen is bold and well-intentioned. The technology offers clear advantages, especially for long-distance or commercial applications that require fast charging and long range. However, for personal mobility, the future of hydrogen remains highly uncertain.
The English, Chinese, Japanese, Arabic, and French versions are automatically generated by the AI. So there may still be inaccuracies in translating, please always see Indonesian as our main language. (system supported by DigitalSiber.id)
